Translate

Sunday, January 12, 2014

Three Parenting Trends Christians Should Avoid


 Come, my children, listen to me; I will teach you the fear of the Lord~ Psalm 34:11

Last week, while waiting to go through security at the Phoenix airport, I witnessed something weird. It’s probably not what you think.

My attention was drawn to the neighboring security line when I heard a woman’s voice repeating softly and sweetly—and then more loudly and frantically—“No, thank you,” “No, thank you.”

I’m not generally all that curious early in the morning, but this captured my interest. I scanned the adjacent line and tried to figure out what was making her repeat “No, thank you” so hysterically.

Then I noticed a cute little boy, maybe three years old, running gleefully down the security line, ramming his head into the back of random passengers’ legs. The lucky ones saw him coming and dodged his attack. The rest had bruises to attend when he was through with them.

The boy’s Mother stood helplessly by as her adorable little thug assaulted clueless bystanders. I was baffled as to why an apparently intelligent woman would stand by and say no thank you to a child who was attacking strangers. Seizing the child, restraining him and reprimanding his rudeness seemed to me a more sensible and effective solution to his terrorist-like tactics.

  Then I recalled a child development class my daughter took in high school. The instructor (a very nice woman with a Masters degree) taught the students that it’s damaging to tell young children “no.” Instead, they should be told “no thank you” in order to preserve their fragile self-worth.  When my daughter told me about her teacher’s theory I rolled my eyes and casually dismissed it as a passing fad accepted only in the world of academia.

Apparently this ridiculous fad has caught on in the real world. I found several websites dedicated to “positive parenting” that encouraged the use of this technique with young children. A Christian friend with young children confirmed that many parents—even some Christian parents—embrace this parenting trend.

I don’t pretend to know everything there is to know about parenting. I do know enough to tell you that some of the ideas being floated around by experts are just plain crazy. Today I will highlight three crazy trends every Christian parent should run away from…

 
 Experts Know Best Parenting~

The abundance of experts who hold advanced degrees in phycology, theology, education and medicine has caused some parents to doubt their own ability make sound decisions. This has resulted in many parents outsourcing instruction and parenting decisions to teachers, pastors, doctors and psychologists. Expert advice can be helpful, but at the end of the day experts are people. People make mistakes, are sometimes misguided or just plain wrong, and don’t always know what’s best for every child in every situation. Wise and discerning parents seek an abundance of human counsel (Proverbs 11:14) and prayerfully consider all the options before they (not the experts) make decisions that might have long-term physical, academic, moral, or spiritual consequences for their child.

Teacup Parenting~

Teacup parents believe that children are fragile and need to be protected from the losses and disappointments that are a natural part of life. Children do need to be protected from harmful people and philosophies, but not from the reality that life is sometimes hard. We need to help children understand that no one will be successful at everything they attempt. In order to become healthy, functional adults kids need to learn that sometimes they will get hurt, lose or fail. We need to let life teach kids that getting hurt rarely kills them, and losing or failing doesn’t make them unlovable and it doesn’t have to define them.

Positive Parenting~ 

Positive parenting sounds great. After all, who wants to be a negative, nasty parent? Proponents of this philosophy teach that discipline is destructive and that children should be affirmed in every situation. This sort of thinking is well intentioned but dangerously misguided. This viewpoint flies in the face of biblical instruction (Proverbs 6:23,12:1, 12:24,22:6, 22:15, Ephesians 6:4, Hebrews 12:5-10, Hebrews 12:11) and if followed is destined to produce foolish adults and heartbroken parents (Proverbs 17:5). Kids need firm boundaries and loving correction; affirmation should be reserved for times when their behavior is worthy of it.

  Good parenting is not just about making kids comfortable, happy or popular with other children, and it is certainly not about having your kids like you right now. Good parenting is about making kids capable, responsible, well mannered, godly and likeable to other people.

 The greatest tragedy of the scene I witnessed in the airport was that none of the adults in the airport liked the cute little guy involved. It’s not the child’s fault; he was too young to know better. It’s not the fault of the adults in the airport; no one should expect to be assaulted while traveling. The fault lies entirely with his Mother for not making him behave in a way that makes him likeable to other people.

 Parents get it all wrong when they take a short view of the parenting process and forget that their cute little kids will not stay little forever. Kids become adults, and what kind of adult they grow into is almost entirely dependent on what type of training they receive when they are small.

 Every parenting philosophy or choice should be evaluated not on the basis of ease, or whether or not it makes kids happy now, but on whether or not it makes them holy, responsible, well-mannered and likable people when it really matters.   

  Children, obey your parents in everything, for this pleases the Lord. Fathers, do not embitter your children, or they will become discouraged~ Colossians 3:20-21 

No comments:

Post a Comment